Is your broker getting you the best insurance deal?


Going too low on insurance cover is risky for any business. But how can you be sure your insurance premiums are in line with market rates?

The stakes are high, too, with Marsh’s quarterly Global Insurance Market Index reporting that international commercial insurance pricing increased by an average of 15 per cent in the second quarter of 2021. Prices in the Pacific region, where Australia is the largest market, rose by a staggering 23 per cent.

In such an environment, the performance of your insurance broker is critical to ensure you maintain an optimal insurance program, regardless of the market cycle. However, they are not a silver bullet, and it is crucial that your broker understands your business’s situation and needs to deliver the best insurance policies possible, and within budget. Following are some smart ways to get the most out of your broker.

1. Conduct a broker tender process

An independent insurance consultancy can help businesses implement and manage a competitive tender process for the provision of insurance broking services.

Even though you may be satisfied with your incumbent broker, such a check makes sense and can often reveal weaknesses in your insurance approach that might otherwise go unnoticed, whether that is related to costs, cover or even the broker itself. Such a tender analysis should factor in whether the broker has specialist expertise and a proven record in your particular sector.

2. Set appropriate KPIs

In locking in a broker, it is important to factor in pre-agreed key performance indicators (KPIs) that match your business’s particular insurance requirements and service expectations. By clearly defining those deliverables, which should be linked to the broker’s remuneration, there is greater transparency and both parties are more likely to be satisfied over the long term.

3. Ask how premiums will be calculated

Many businesses simply buy insurance without realising what drives their insurance premiums, and what level of information is necessary to negotiate the cheapest possible rates. A good insurance broker should be able to advise about some of the factors at play here.

For example, approaching an insurer for renewal terms using low-quality or ambiguous information surrounding a  company’s risks (and subsequent insurance needs)  can push up premiums, as insurers typically fill any gaps in information with premiums.  Your broker should inform you of this and offer strategies that ensure your company risks are clearly conveyed using high-quality data that presents your business to insurers in the best possible light.

Be sure, too, that you are not paying any hidden commissions or fees to your broker.

4. Review your policy wordings

Carrying out policy wording reviews of your key classes of insurance is important – and something a good broker should be across. They must be able to provide feedback on areas of possible improvement because subtle differences in the wording of policies can make all the difference as to whether coverage exists or not.
5. Examine your broker’s research capacity

Solid research should be at the heart of a broker’s insurance recommendations. That research helps identify any existing or emerging industry risks, and it informs relevant insights into insurance needs.
No one broker has exclusivity of good ideas, so businesses should quiz brokers about their research practices, knowing that the best research is likely to lead to the best insurance outcomes.
Help is at hand to analyse your business’s insurance policies and to check if your broker is getting you the best available deal with the lowest possible fees. So click here now to contact a specialist consultancy group that can guide you through the insurance maze. Don’t delay.
To find why you should test the adequacy of your insurance arrangements periodically, find out more.

Mastering the request for Proposal process

Only the right process and the right people will achieve the right results.

Subscribe for insurance market updates

Get regular updates plus all the latest Lion Partnership insights.

Get in touch today

Our industry-leading consultancy team can help your organisation make the most out of its insurance costs.